The DARK SIDE of REMODELING
CBS Marketwatch
MAY 16, 2002
 
 

            Home renovation and remodeling is a $106 billion-a-year business. The fuel that continues to propel this activity is the rapid rise in property values, interest rates continuing to hover near 40-year lows and free-flowing home-equity loans.

 
            Been inside a Home Depot or Lowes Home Improvement Center lately? Even while the economy sputters, business is brisk. Rather than invest money into a stock market that continues to dish out punishing losses, homeowners opt to pump cash into their homes.

            Yet an unhealthy trend is beginning to emerge.
 
RETURN ON INVESTMENT IS SLIPPING

            While homeowners continue to pour their cash and savings into their homes, anyone vying for the attention of a contractor to get their job done will tell you that they have no bargaining power-- demand exceeds the supply of skilled and experienced contractors. Combine this with a "money invested in the house is a sure thing" attitude and the fact that almost any homeowner with a heartbeat can get a home-equity loan these days and you have the makings of undisciplined and excessive spending by homeowners on their remodeling projects.
 

        The following survey results sure paint the same picture:
 
 

Project
1998*
2001*
2001 Average Cost
Minor Kitchen Remodel
94%
88%
$14,773
Major Kitchen Remodel
87%
81%
$38,769
Family Room Addition
84%
80%
$46,738
Master Suite
82%
75%
$63,275
Attic Bedroom
82%
74%
$31,366
Bathroom Remodel
89%
85%
$9,455
Deck Addition
70%
77%
$5,865
        * Return on Cost if sold within a year of the improvement
        ** Source: National Assoc. of Realtors
 

PROJECT AND LOCATION MATTER

        According to the 2001 Cost vs. Value Survey by Remodeling and Realtor magazines, while kitchen and bathroom remodeling and family room additions seem to have the best resale value, the cost recovery on sale can vary significantly by region.

 

Project
Washington DC
San Francisco
Boston
Albany, NY
Minor Kitchen Remodel
120%
133%
110%
87%
Bathroom Remodel
125%
152%
71%
64%
Family Room Addition
131%
150%
185%
73%
Deck Addition
111%
147%
139%
52%
Basement Refinish
94%
154%
48%
39%
 
Adapted from Realtor Magazine and Remodeling magazine, using costs and values for the North East home market.
 
            Apparently in areas where building lots and desirable homes are in tight supply, remodeling a home can really pay off. In areas where lots are less expensive or there is a more normal real estate market, remodeling costs are less likely to be recovered on sale.

            Regardless of what region your home is in, before you decide on any remodeling projects, do your research on what your best options are relative to similar homes in your area. It's wise to tour a few homes during open houses and even visit several new developments to see what features are included in newly constructed homes. Also, visit Remodeling online and review their 2001 Cost versus Value Survey for your region. If you're thinking of selling your home in the next few years, you might reconsider that basement remodeling you were about to jump into.
 

PLANNING PAYS

            Homeowners should approach making a home improvement similar to making an investment and not get swept up in the excitement of a modern addition or updated kitchen. Most home improvement experts agree that the key to a successful home remodeling or improvement project is organization and planning. Define exactly what it is that you want to get done, get quotes and preliminary bids and work up a budget. In short, do your homework before you invest.
 

WHAT TO GET IN WRITING

            If you plan on hiring a tradesman or contractor for your project, it's a good idea to get bids or estimates from at least three qualified professionals. When there is strong demand for home improvement services in your area, this will be difficult to do, but don't skip this step.

            Check references, ask to see similar completed jobs, request to see copies of general liability and workers compensation insurance certificates. Always ask for a written contract before you pay any money or begin work. The contract should include these elements:
 

PAYING FOR IT

                Although the majority of homeowners pay for renovations from savings, there are several other options to consider for refinancing your project:
 



 
HOME
 
ACCOUNT INFORMATION
VALUE INVESTING
PORTFOLIO REPORTS 
FINANCIAL PLANNING
SEC REPORTS
 MIKE
 
NANCY
NANCYCUSHING 
CLIENT PET PICTURES 
PET PICTURES
TRIVIA
QUESTIONS