Business
Succession Planning
Whatever
type of business you own, you need to arrange for the transfer of the business
or partnership at your retirement, incapacitation, or death. If the family
members will continue the business after your death, make sure you have
enough cash available to cover estate taxes or other expenses or they may
have to sell assets of the company to pay the bills (life insurance is
an excellent source of funds for these expenses). A buy-sell agreement
can be used to help avoid unexpected surprises and make the transactions
smoother, but there are several issues to address before the agreement
can be done. Professional advice is absolutely necessary for any of these
actions.
VALUING THE
BUSINESS
One of the first steps in business
succession planning is to determine the value of your business. Your business
may be the most significant asset in our estate and without proper planning,
you may be subject to significant estate taxes at your death. Because of
the lack of an open market for family-owned businesses, arriving at an
appropriate value for stock in a closely-held business can be a complex
undertaking. Usually, the opinion of one or more independent appraisers
is needed.
What do appraisers look at when they are valuing a business. The following
are all factors that are considered, but business valuation is an inexact
science and courts have been known to strike down valuations that they've
deemed to be too low or too high.
-
The nature of the business and
its history: Is there competition or does the company have a niche? Is
it cyclical?
-
The financial condition of the
company: Are there financial problems or is the company sound?
-
The economic outlook of the
industry
-
The book value, earnings capacity,
and the dividend-paying capacity of the company.
-
Stock prices of publicly traded
companies in a similar industry.
Once a value has been determined, it can then be discounted due to various
factors.
-
Minority shares:
If the transfer is not giving away
control, the value of the transfer is reduced. Individual with minority
interests generally can't influence the management of the company or make
any significant decisions.
-
Lack of marketability:
The valuation is based on the assumption that there is a willing buyer
for the shares being transferred. In fact, there are probably few buyers
in the open market who would be interested in a piece of a family-owned
business.
-
Key Person:
What if the person leaving the company is the one who brings in most of
the business? Or creates all the ideas? Or is the only one customers will
deal with? A key person discount can be quite significant if it can be
proven. It can also apply to a key employee as well as an owner.
BUY-SELL
AGREEMENTS
If you plan to sell the business to a family member, partner, employee,
or an outside party, serious consideration should be given to a buy-sell
agreement. An agreement:
-
Provides for an orderly transfer
of the business
-
Permits present co-owners and
family members to continue in their business roles
-
Allows for a fair market value
price for the business (or at least provides a formula for determining
the value).
-
Provides funds for the purchase
-
Lets the owner plan for estate
taxes ahead of time
Life insurance is a popular way to provide the cash needed to complete
the buyout. Usually, there is a life insurance on the owner(s), or key
employee(s) with the company as the beneficiary. The spouse of the decedent
would own the shares upon the death of the owner and the company would
use the proceeds of the life insurance policy to buyback the shares for
the surviving spouse.
OWNERSHIP
FORMS
-
FAMILY LIMITED
PARTNERSHIP
In general, a family partnership strategy is most attractive to owners
of unincorporated businesses. For instance, a family partnership may be
formed with your children or other family members and the owner would continue
to operate the business as the general partner. The important consideration
is to avoid incurring gift taxes. The limited partnership interests could
be given to the children (or other family members) on a tax free basis
using the $10,000 annual gift exclusion. Or, the shares could be sold at
a fair market value price and again, gift taxes would be avoided.
As limited partners, your children would have no control over the business'
management and there would be limited legal liability for partnership debts
and actions.
For income-tax purposes, all partnership income, expenses, gains, losses,
deductions, and credits, would pass through to the general partner and
the limited partners.
For estate-tax purposes, the value of the interests transferred to family
members and any appreciation on those interests, would be removed from
the owner's taxable estate.
-
TRUSTS TO HOLD
S CORPORATION STOCK
If your business is an S corporation,
your stock may comprise a substantial portion of your estate. If the surviving
family members do not have the desire or the expertise to manage the business
after the owner's death, a trust incorporated into your Will may be the
best solution. The Will creates a trust that would hold the shares of the
S corp.'s stock and the management would be appointed through the terms
of the will and trust. Also, a living trust could be created to hold the
shares while the owner is alive, but it must be carefully structured to
continue after their death.
In either case, only certain types of trusts are eligible to hold S corporation
stock so the trust must be designed carefully. If you transfer your S corp.
stock to a nonqualifying trust, the corporation's S status may be terminated.
The result would be severe federal income-tax consequences so professional
advice is vital.